Ranger Valve America

Technical Guide

Slab gate vs expanding gate valves: what is the difference?

The short answer

Both are API 6D through-conduit gate valves: full bore for pigging, with a bore-sized hole in the gate and two seat rings. The difference is how the gate seals. A slab gate is a single floating plate that line pressure pushes onto the downstream seat. An expanding gate is a two-piece gate that is mechanically forced outward against both seats at the open and closed positions, so its seal does not depend on line pressure.

Ranger Valve America Ltd. · Last reviewed

What a through conduit gate valve is

In a through conduit gate valve the gate has a hole the same size as the pipe bore. With the valve fully open, that hole lines up with the two seat rings and the body bore, so the flow path is uninterrupted. Pressure loss is minimal, and pigs, scrapers and hot-tap cutters can pass straight through.

With the gate fully open the seat sealing faces are out of the flow stream, so they are not exposed to the erosive action of the medium or to debris from pigging. That extends seat life. These are pipeline valves, used for crude and refined oil, natural gas liquids, gas, chemical, water and slurry service. Both designs below are designed to API 6D; for how that differs from the wedge gate valves in API 600, see API 6D vs API 600 valves.

How a slab gate valve seals

A slab gate valve has a one-piece floating slab and two floating seat rings that line pressure assists. When the valve is closed, pressure on the upstream side pushes the upstream seat ring and the floating slab toward the downstream seat ring until the slab seals against it, as if the line had been closed with a blind flange. The seat rings work in a similar way to the single-piston-effect seats of a trunnion ball valve, and the floating slab is similar to the floating ball of a floating ball valve.

The result is a bi-directional seal with block, isolation and bleed capability per API 6D. RANGER reports that the seating torque of its slab gate valve is approximately 25% lower than that of an API 600 wedge gate valve of similar size and pressure rating.

How an expanding gate valve seals

An expanding gate is built from two pieces, the gate and a segment, with mating inclined faces. While the gate travels between open and closed, the two pieces stay retracted and the seat rings are not in contact with the gate, which is why seat wear and operating torque are lower than in a slab gate valve.

Just before the fully open or fully closed position, the segment meets an internal mechanical stop. Continued handwheel travel makes the gate ride up the incline, expanding the gate assembly in width until both sealing faces press against the seat rings. The harder the handwheel is turned, the tighter the seal. Because the seal is made mechanically, it does not depend on line pressure: it holds at zero, low and high differential pressure, and regardless of vibration or body flexing from pipeline bending.

Slab and expanding gate valves compared

Slab gateExpanding gate
Closing memberOne-piece floating slabTwo-piece gate and segment that expand
What forces the gate onto the seatLine pressure pushes the slab and upstream seat onto the downstream seatMechanical expansion at the end of travel; independent of line pressure
Operating torqueSeating torque about 25% lower than an equivalent API 600 wedge gate valveLower than an equivalent slab gate valve
Seat service lifeSeats are out of the flow stream when openExtended further: seats are not in contact with the gate while it travels
Typical servicePipeline isolation of crude oil, refined products, NGLs and gasHigh-temperature refinery service, power plant isolation, critical pipeline blocks
Cavity reliefInternal cavity pressure relief, with stem and seat sealant injectionInternal or external cavity pressure relief option, with stem and seat sealant injection
RANGER size2" – 48"2" – 48"
RANGER class150 – 2500150 – 2500

Which one should you specify?

  • Start with the service and the project specification. Pipeline isolation of oil, NGLs and gas is the traditional home of the slab gate valve.
  • High-temperature service, or a critical block valve where you do not want the seal to depend on line pressure: look at an expanding gate valve.
  • Both designs are full bore for pigging. Neither is meant for throttling: a partly open gate valve exposes the gate and seats to the flow.
  • Ask for the operating torque at your maximum differential pressure for the actuator or gearbox sizing, and ask whether the seats are soft or metal. RANGER lists API 6D / ISO 5208 leakage rates of Rate A for soft seats and Rate D for metal seats.
  • Confirm the fire test (API 6FA), the fugitive-emission requirement, and any need for extended stems (buried service) or cryogenic service.

Slab and expanding gate valves from RANGER

RANGER through conduit slab gate valves run 2" – 48", Class 150 – 2500, and expanding gate valves run 2" – 48", Class 150 – 2500. Both have a bolted bonnet for top-entry inspection, repair and replacement without removing the valve from the line, an anti-blowout back-seat stem, and stem and seat sealant injection. Optional features include cryogenic service, extended stems for buried service and chain wheel operated gearboxes.

See through conduit slab gate valves and expanding gate valves. Both are also available in the specialty gate valves range.

Frequently asked questions

Is a slab gate valve full bore?

Yes. The slab has a hole the size of the bore, so with the valve open the flow path is straight through, which allows pigging and gives very little pressure drop.

Which seals better at low pressure, a slab or an expanding gate valve?

A slab gate valve is energized by line pressure. An expanding gate valve seals mechanically at the end of travel, so its seal does not depend on line pressure, including at zero differential pressure.

Can a gate valve be used to throttle flow?

No. Gate valves are for fully open or fully closed isolation. A partly open gate exposes the gate and seat faces to the flow, which can damage the sealing surfaces.

How is a slab gate valve different from an API 600 wedge gate valve?

An API 600 gate valve wedges into its seats, while a slab gate floats between two seat rings and is pushed against the downstream seat by line pressure. RANGER reports roughly 25% lower seating torque for its slab gate than for an equivalent API 600 wedge gate.

Can the valve be repaired without removing it from the line?

Yes, after the system is depressurized. The bolted bonnet gives top entry for inspection, repair and replacement of the internal parts without taking the valve out of the pipeline.

Request the brochure

The API 6D Slab and Expanding Gate Valves catalogue covers both designs in detail: sealing and stem arrangements, fire-safe seat behaviour, packing options, key components and dimensions.

Select what you'd like below and we'll email you secure download links.

Catalogue